logo

Dean Phillips' Potential Challenge Unsettles Non-White Democrats in New Hampshire

Minnesota Representative Dean Phillips' anticipated decision to launch a Democratic primary challenge against President Joe Biden has stirred discontent among prominent non-white members of the party. The move, expected to commence with filing for the New Hampshire primary, has sparked criticism, with some arguing it reflects a "disregard" for the Democratic Party's emphasis on the South and diverse voters.

Expressing their dissatisfaction, a senior Black Democrat, speaking anonymously, remarked, "He's skipping a very diverse state to go to a non-diverse state," interpreting it as indicative of Phillips' values. Despite repeated teases of a potential bid against Biden, Phillips' team has not commented on the matter. The expectation is that he will file for New Hampshire's primary, given the approaching deadline.

Phillips, a former member of House Democratic leadership, had previously stated, "I think the country would be well served by a new generation of compelling, well-prepared, dynamic Democrats to step up." However, launching a campaign in New Hampshire, traditionally the first primary state, has drawn attention and criticism for allegedly neglecting the emphasis on diversity.

Critics argue that Phillips' decision not to file for Nevada's Democratic primary and the limited time to enter South Carolina's primary indicate a disregard for states chosen by the Democratic National Committee and endorsed by Biden. South Carolina, in particular, was selected to lead the new nominating calendar due to its representation of geographic and racial diversity, especially among Black Democrats.

The discontent reflects broader tensions in the Democratic Party regarding the rearrangement of the primary calendar, with New Hampshire Democrats feeling slighted and potential consequences for the state's delegates in the wake of scheduling disputes. The evolving situation suggests a complex interplay between regional representation, diversity, and the strategic positioning of candidates in the Democratic primary landscape.

The criticism against Dean Phillips intensifies as a senior Black Democrat suggests that Phillips is strategically avoiding scrutiny and questions from the significant Black voter demographic in South Carolina. Describing it as self-serving, the source emphasized, "I think it's BS and it's all about him." Notably, Phillips has not sought counsel from the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC), a pivotal group for understanding the concerns of the constituency, according to Rep. Bennie Thompson, a CBC member and institute chair.

Thompson expressed concern over the lack of outreach from Phillips, stating that any private overtures made have not resonated. Characterizing Phillips' potential launch in New Hampshire as "divisive and disrespectful," Thompson believes it undermines a substantial population and support base for the Democratic Party.

The South Carolina Democratic Party reported no contact from Phillips, and their state chair, Christale Spain, criticized his choice to disregard the state's historic primary, which emphasizes the voices of Black, rural, and Southern voters. Spain labeled Phillips as an "unserious candidate."

Furthermore, Phillips has not reached out to the Congressional Hispanic Caucus, highlighting a lack of engagement with diverse constituencies. Rep. Nanette Barragán, the group's chair, noted this absence and emphasized the unity within the Democratic Party, which has drawn criticism from figures like Phillips and Marianne Williamson, who advocate for fresh leadership given Biden's declining approval ratings.

Antjuan Seawright, a Democratic political strategist, labeled Phillips' potential preference for New Hampshire a mistake, emphasizing South Carolina's heightened political importance in the 2024 primary race. Drawing parallels to Biden's own success in South Carolina during the 2020 primaries, Seawright noted the necessity of strong, equal support in the state for political traction.

In the midst of these criticisms, the senior Democrat expressed a broader concern that Phillips' approach deviates from the party's efforts to represent the diversity of America, suggesting it could lead to a path of losing rather than winning. As the dynamics unfold, Phillips faces growing scrutiny for his strategic decisions in the lead-up to the 2024 Democratic primaries.

In conclusion, Dean Phillips' potential Democratic primary challenge against President Joe Biden has sparked significant controversy, particularly among non-white Democrats. The criticism centers on Phillips' strategic decision to launch a campaign by filing for the New Hampshire primary, seen by some as a disregard for the emphasis on diversity and key states like South Carolina within the Democratic Party.

The senior Black Democrat's suggestion that Phillips is avoiding scrutiny from Black voters in South Carolina adds a layer of concern, with accusations of self-interest overshadowing broader party considerations. The lack of consultation with influential groups like the Congressional Black Caucus and the Congressional Hispanic Caucus further underscores a perceived disconnect with diverse constituencies.

Representative Bennie Thompson expressed concern about the lack of outreach from Phillips, deeming his potential launch in New Hampshire divisive and disrespectful to a significant Democratic support base. Criticism from the South Carolina Democratic Party and the Congressional Hispanic Caucus adds weight to the argument that Phillips may be viewed as an unserious candidate, neglecting crucial voices in the party.

Antjuan Seawright's warning about the political importance of South Carolina in the 2024 primary race serves as a cautionary note for Phillips, emphasizing the necessity of strong support in the state for political traction. The overarching concern expressed by a senior Democrat is that Phillips' direction may lead the party away from representing the diversity of America and towards a path of losing rather than winning.

As the situation unfolds, the scrutiny on Dean Phillips highlights the complex interplay between strategic decisions, regional representation, and the party's commitment to inclusivity, ultimately shaping the narrative of the 2024 Democratic primaries.