logo

Unraveling Tragedy: The Intersection of a Stolen Phone and a Murder Trial Involving Two Alaska Native Women

Unraveling a Gruesome Mystery: The Double Murder Trial of Two Alaska Native Women

In Anchorage, a harrowing double murder trial is underway, shedding light on the brutal killings of two Alaska Native women. The investigation was sparked by the discovery of graphic video and photographs depicting a hotel-room assault on a memory card handed over to police in 2019. These disturbing images led authorities to uncover the remains of one victim and identify a suspect in her murder.

Brian Steven Smith, 52, was apprehended in October 2019 in connection with the death of 30-year-old Kathleen Henry, the victim depicted in the photos and video. Amidst the investigation into Henry's murder, Smith was also arrested for the killing of Veronica Abouchuk, 52, days later. Smith now faces a slew of charges, including first- and second-degree murder, and tampering with evidence, in relation to their deaths. He maintains his innocence.

The pivotal moment in the case came when a woman, Valerie Casler, claimed to have stumbled upon an SD card labeled "Homicide at midtown Marriott" on September 30, 2019. Casler admitted to stealing the phone from Smith's truck and transferring its contents to the SD card before turning it over to the authorities. Little did she know, this seemingly insignificant act would become the linchpin of the investigation.

The memory card contained chilling footage from September 2019, showcasing a woman enduring a vicious assault in an Anchorage hotel room. The horrific scenes depicted the victim being beaten, raped, and strangled, with the perpetrator callously laughing as he inflicted harm. Detectives traced Smith's phone to the location where the last image from the SD card was taken, leading to the discovery of Henry's remains near Seward Highway.

Testimonies from witnesses, including Casler, and detective accounts further solidified the case against Smith. David Cordie, a detective with the Anchorage Police Department, noted the striking resemblance between the voice in the footage and Smith's, based on his prior interactions with the suspect.

As the trial progresses, the haunting details of this case continue to captivate the public's attention, underscoring the urgency of seeking justice for the victims and their grieving families.

In his opening statement, Timothy Ayer, representing Brian Steven Smith, cast doubt on the validity of the video footage and questioned the credibility of Valerie Casler's testimony, highlighting inconsistencies in her account over the years. Ayer asserted that law enforcement attempted to construct a narrative based on their interpretation of the video, suggesting a potential bias in their investigation.

Veronica Abouchuk, the second victim, was last seen by her relatives in July 2018 and reported missing by her family in February 2019. During an interview related to Kathleen Henry's case in October 2019, Smith allegedly confessed to shooting a woman between 2017 and 2018 and provided information about her body's location. Subsequently, a skull with a gunshot wound discovered near the specified location in April 2019 was identified as belonging to Abouchuk.

Prosecutors contended that Smith targeted vulnerable women, alleging that he picked up Abouchuk, who struggled with homelessness, and fatally shot her when she refused to take a shower at his home in mid-August 2018.

Ayer raised concerns about the state's evidence, citing "holes" and "issues" during the proceedings. The trial, which has experienced previous delays, is anticipated to span three to four weeks.

As the trial unfolds, the quest for justice for the victims and their families continues, with the proceedings poised to illuminate the intricacies of a complex and tragic case.

In conclusion, the trial of Brian Steven Smith for the double murder of two Alaska Native women has commenced amidst a flurry of legal proceedings and contentious arguments. As Timothy Ayer, Smith's lawyer, challenges the validity of evidence and raises doubts about witness testimonies, the case underscores the importance of a thorough and impartial judicial process.

The tragic deaths of Kathleen Henry and Veronica Abouchuk serve as a stark reminder of the vulnerabilities faced by marginalized individuals in society. Prosecutors allege that Smith preyed upon these vulnerabilities, perpetrating heinous acts against the victims.

Despite the complexities and delays that have plagued the trial, the pursuit of justice for Henry and Abouchuk remains steadfast. As the legal proceedings unfold over the course of the next few weeks, the outcome of the trial will carry significant implications for both the victims' families and the broader community.

Ultimately, the trial represents a critical juncture in the quest to hold perpetrators of violent crimes accountable and provide closure to those affected by senseless acts of violence.